Mastering the No Comment Interview Strategy
No comment is a legitimate, often sensible choice. It isn't a default, and it isn't a sign of guilt. Used well, it protects a client who can't safely give an account yet. Used badly, it can lose them a defence. This page is about deciding on no comment and holding it in the interview. For the law on inferences, see Adverse inference: Section 34.
When no comment is likely to be right
- Disclosure is inadequate. You can't advise on an account if you don't know the allegation (R v Imran and Hussain [1997] Crim LR 754).
- The client is unfit or vulnerable and an account may be unreliable.
- The client has no defence to put forward, and anything they say may only help the prosecution.
- The matter is complex or historic, and the client needs to check records before committing to details.
- There's a real risk the client will incriminate themselves on other matters, or implicate others in ways that harm them.
When it may not be
- The client has a clear, simple defence (for example self-defence or alibi) that they'll rely on at trial. Not mentioning it risks an inference, and a full account now may lead to NFA.
- The evidence is weak and the client's account could end the case.
- An out-of-court disposal is realistically available, and needs an admission.
In those cases, consider an account, or a prepared statement setting out the key facts followed by no comment.
Explaining it to the client
Make sure they understand:
- Silence may lead to an inference at trial if they later rely on facts they could have mentioned.
- A prepared statement may reduce that risk if it covers everything they'll rely on.
- The decision is theirs, made on your advice.
- If they choose no comment, they need to stick with it. Partial answers can be the worst of both worlds.
Holding it in interview
- At the start, read a short statement on the record:
"My client has been advised by me not to answer questions at this stage because [reasons, for example limited disclosure]. They'll be following that advice."
- Remind the client they can answer "no comment" to every question, including ones that seem harmless.
- Watch for common pressure tactics: "This is your chance to tell your side", "Innocent people answer questions", or long silences. Intervene if questioning becomes oppressive, misleading or repetitive. Stay calm and professional.
- If new evidence is disclosed during the interview, ask for a break to take instructions.
Afterwards
Record the advice, the reasons, the client's decision, and anything said in the interview. If the client later relies on your advice to explain their silence, the court will consider whether that reliance was genuine and reasonable (R v Beckles [2005] 1 Cr App R 23).
Sources
- Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, s.34 (legislation.gov.uk)
- PACE Code C 2023 (GOV.UK): para 10.5 (the caution) and Annex C
General information only.