Dealing with Police: Professional Relationships and Managing Custody Officers
You'll deal with the same custody sergeants, detention officers and investigators again and again. Good working relationships help your clients. But your job is to protect the client's rights, and sometimes that means saying things officers don't want to hear. The trick is to be firm, polite and precise.
Who's who
- Custody officer (usually a sergeant): responsible for the detainee's detention, rights and welfare, and for the custody record. They decide whether detention is authorised, and later how the suspect is dealt with when there is enough evidence to charge (PACE s.37(7)). In cases the DPP's Guidance on Charging allocates to the police, the custody officer can charge. In all other cases the CPS makes the charging decision, and the custody officer can release the suspect on bail, or keep them in detention, so that the CPS can decide (s.37(7)(a)). Custody officer functions must not be carried out by an officer involved in the investigation, subject to limited exceptions (PACE s.36(5) to (7)).
- Detention officers / custody staff: day-to-day care, under the custody officer.
- Officer in the case (OIC) / interviewing officers: run the investigation and the interview, and give you disclosure.
- Review officer: before charge, an officer of at least the rank of inspector who is not directly involved in the investigation carries out the PACE s.40 reviews; after charge, the custody officer does them (s.40(1)). You can make representations at a review (s.40(12)).
- Superintendent: authorises extensions to 36 hours, delays to legal advice, and urgent interviews.
Getting the basics right
- Phone ahead. Tell custody you're coming and ask about the client: offence, time of arrest, interview plans, any welfare issues.
- Ask to see the custody record as soon as you arrive. The detainee's solicitor must be allowed to inspect the whole of it (Code C 2.4).
- Be on time, or tell them if you won't be.
- Keep it professional. No sarcasm, no shouting, no point-scoring.
Negotiating
Disclosure
Ask the OIC specific questions, and ask for written disclosure. If it's thin, say so politely, note it, and explain that it will affect your advice. See Reading Police Disclosure.
Bail and conditions
Put proposals to the custody officer: address, work, ties, and conditions that address the risk. Ask for the reasons for any decision to be recorded.
Timing of interview
If the client isn't fit, or you need more time with them, say so and explain why. Most officers will agree to reasonable requests.
Challenging breaches
When something's wrong (a missed review, no AA, rest periods ignored, interview without advice):
- Raise it with the officer concerned, calmly and specifically: what's wrong, and which provision.
- Ask for it to be recorded on the custody record.
- Escalate to the custody officer, then the duty inspector, if needed.
- Note times, names and responses in your attendance note.
Keep the tone neutral: "Sergeant, the client hasn't had eight hours' rest in the last 24 under Code C 12.2. Can you note that, and can we put the interview back?"
When it gets difficult
Some officers will be obstructive, rude or dismissive of reps. Don't take the bait. Stay polite, put your point clearly, and record it. If it's affecting the client's rights, escalate. If it's just unpleasant, note it and move on. Serious misconduct can be raised with the firm, which can complain.
Your independence
Officers may be friendly. That's fine. But don't discuss the client's instructions or your advice, don't give the police an "off the record" view, and remember that anything you say may end up in the record.
Sources
General information only.