Police Disclosure Explained

What the police should tell the legal adviser before interview, how reps use disclosure to advise, and what to do when it's thin. General information, not legal advice.

Last updated: 29 October 2026 · Author: Robert Cashman, Duty Solicitor & Higher Court Advocate

The short answer

Before a suspect is interviewed, PACE Code C paragraph 11.1A says the suspect and their solicitor “must be given sufficient information to enable them to understand the nature of any such offence, and why they are suspected of committing it” (Code C, para 11.1A). The Notice of Rights and Entitlements puts it this way: the police must give you and your solicitor “enough information about what the police think you have done so you can defend yourself but not at a time which would harm the police investigation” (Notice of Rights, section 6).

That is not the same as seeing all the evidence. Full prosecution disclosure under the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 (CPIA) comes later, once a case is in court. This guide explains what Code C requires, what the police can hold back, how representatives use what they are given, and how disclosure interacts with silence, pre-charge engagement and the CPIA.

Who this guide is for

Accredited representatives and solicitors preparing for police station interviews; suspects and families who want to understand what the police should say before questions start; and trainees working towards the Police Station Qualification. It is general information about the law of England and Wales, not legal advice on any individual case.

What Code C requires before interview

The duty sits in Code C paragraph 11.1A. The information must be enough “to enable them to understand the nature of any such offence, and why they are suspected of committing it”, and the stated purpose is “to allow for the effective exercise of the rights of the defence”. It cross-refers to paragraph 3.4(a) (recording the offence and reasons for arrest) and paragraph 10.3.

Paragraph 10.3 adds that an arrested person “must be informed at the time if practicable or, if not, as soon as it becomes practicable thereafter, that they are under arrest and of the grounds and reasons for their arrest” (Code C, para 10.3). The Notice of Rights repeats that “Before you are asked any questions about any offence, the police must give you and your solicitor enough information about what the police think you have done” (Notice of Rights, section 6).

Practice note (not a Code requirement): the information is usually given by the officer in a briefing to the legal adviser before the private consultation. Code C does not prescribe a format, but it does require a record (see below).

The minimum: Note 11ZA

Note for guidance 11ZA explains what “sufficient” means. It says the requirement “applies prior to the interview and whether or not they are legally represented”, and that what is sufficient “will depend on the circumstances of the case, but it should normally include, as a minimum, a description of the facts relating to the suspected offence that are known to the officer, including the time and place in question” (Code C, Note 11ZA).

The note gives the reason: it “aims to avoid suspects being confused or unclear about what they are supposed to have done and to help an innocent suspect to clear the matter up more quickly”. A bare offence label (for example, “assault” with no date, place or facts) is unlikely to meet that minimum.

What Code C requires as a minimum (Note 11ZA)

  • A description of the facts relating to the suspected offence that are known to the officer
  • The time and place in question
  • Enough to understand the nature of the offence and why you are suspected of it (para 11.1A)

What a representative may ask for (the officer decides)

  • Whether there are witness accounts, and their gist
  • Whether there is CCTV, body-worn video, phone or other digital material, and what it is said to show
  • Any forensic or medical material, or whether results are awaited
  • Any significant statement or silence the officer intends to put at the start of interview (para 11.4)
  • Documents essential to challenging the lawfulness of arrest or detention (para 3.4(b)), from the custody officer

The second list is practice guidance on what to ask for, not a legal entitlement. Beyond the Note 11ZA minimum, the investigating officer decides what is disclosed.

What the police can hold back

Code C paragraph 11.1A is explicit that the duty “does not require the disclosure of details at a time which might prejudice the criminal investigation”, and that “The decision about what needs to be disclosed for the purpose of this requirement therefore rests with the investigating officer who has sufficient knowledge of the case to make that decision” (Code C, para 11.1A). The Notice of Rights says the same in plain terms: “not at a time which would harm the police investigation” (Notice of Rights, section 6).

There is a safeguard. “The officer who discloses the information shall make a record of the information disclosed and when it was disclosed. This record may be made in the interview record, in the officer’s report book or other form provided for this purpose” (Code C, para 11.1A). The legal adviser should keep their own note too.

Custody record and detention documents

Custody record. “The detainee’s solicitor and appropriate adult must be permitted to inspect the whole of the detainee’s custody record as soon as practicable after their arrival at the station and at any other time on request, whilst the person is detained” (Code C, para 2.4). This expressly includes the recorded circumstances and reasons for arrest and the grounds for each authorisation to keep the person in custody. The Notice of Rights tells detainees the police must “let you and your solicitor look at these records” (Notice of Rights, section 7).

Copy after release. On leaving detention, the detainee, their legal representative or appropriate adult “shall be given, on request, a copy of the custody record as soon as practicable. This entitlement lasts for 12 months after release” (Code C, para 2.4A). The Notice of Rights: “You can ask the police for a copy of your Custody Record up to 12 months after you leave the police station” (Notice of Rights).

Documents to challenge detention. Separately, “Documents and materials which are essential to effectively challenging the lawfulness of the detainee’s arrest and detention must be made available to the detainee or their solicitor”, and they are “essential” “if they are capable of undermining the reasons and grounds which make the detainee’s arrest and detention necessary” (Code C, para 3.4(b)). The decision rests with the custody officer, in consultation with the investigating officer. The Notice of Rights says “The police must allow you or your solicitor access to documents and materials essential to effectively challenging the lawfulness of your arrest and detention” (Notice of Rights, section 7).

Note 3ZA says how material is made available “is a matter for the investigating officer to determine on a case by case basis”, for example “by supplying a copy or allowing supervised access to view”, but “for view only access, it will be necessary to demonstrate that sufficient time is allowed for the suspect and solicitor to view and consider the documents and materials in question” (Code C, Note 3ZA). This is about the lawfulness of detention, not a general right to see the evidence on the merits.

Voluntary interviews

The same right applies to a voluntary (not under arrest) interview. Before it proceeds the interviewer must tell the suspect about “Their right to information about the offence(s) in question by providing sufficient information to enable them to understand the nature of any such offence(s) and why they are suspected of committing it”, and Code C adds that “It applies whether or not they ask for legal advice” (Code C, para 3.21A(a)). Note 11ZA likewise says the requirement applies “whether or not they are legally represented”.

What to ask the officer for

Practice note (not law): representatives commonly ask, politely and specifically, whether there are witness accounts, CCTV or body-worn video, digital or forensic material, and whether any significant statement or silence will be put at the start of interview. The officer can decline beyond the Note 11ZA minimum, but a specific question gets a specific, recordable answer.

Code C Note 11B also reminds interviewers of the CPIA Code of Practice: “the investigator should pursue all reasonable lines of enquiry, whether these point towards or away from the suspect” (Code C, Note 11B). Practice note (not law): representatives commonly ask what enquiries have been made, and what is awaited.

How representatives use disclosure

Code C Note 6D describes the role: “The solicitor’s only role in the police station is to protect and advance the legal rights of their client”, which “may require the solicitor to give advice which has the effect of the client avoiding giving evidence which strengthens a prosecution case” (Code C, Note 6D). Disclosure is the starting point for that advice. Practice steps (not law):

  • Work out what the allegation actually is, and what the police say links the client to it
  • Spot gaps, inconsistencies or material the officer has not mentioned, and ask about them before interview
  • Take the client’s instructions in private, against what has been disclosed
  • Advise whether to answer questions, give a prepared statement or make no comment, and record the reasons for that advice
  • Note exactly what was disclosed, by whom and when, so it can be shown later why the advice was given

Inside the interview

At the start of an interview, after the caution, the interviewer “shall put to them any significant statement or silence which occurred in the presence and hearing of a police officer or other police staff before the start of the interview” (Code C, para 11.4). A significant statement “is one which appears capable of being used in evidence against the suspect, in particular a direct admission of guilt” (Code C, para 11.4A). Practice note (not a Code requirement): representatives commonly ask before interview whether any such statement is going to be put.

During interview Note 6D allows the solicitor to “intervene in order to seek clarification, challenge an improper question to their client or the manner in which it is put, advise their client not to reply to particular questions, or if they wish to give their client further legal advice” (Code C, Note 6D). Practice note (not a Code requirement): that last option is commonly used where new material is produced in interview and the client needs further advice on it.

Disclosure, silence and adverse inferences

The suspect does not have to answer. The Notice of Rights says: “If you are asked questions about the suspected offence, you do not have to say anything. However, it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in court” (Notice of Rights, section 5).

The legal basis is section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994. It applies where the accused, “on being questioned under caution by a constable trying to discover whether or by whom the offence had been committed, failed to mention any fact relied on in his defence”, “being a fact which in the circumstances existing at the time the accused could reasonably have been expected to mention”; the court or jury “may draw such inferences from the failure as appear proper” (CJPOA 1994, s.34(1) and (2)). At an authorised place of detention no inference may be drawn if the accused “had not been allowed an opportunity to consult a solicitor prior to being questioned, charged or informed” (s.34(2A)); the Crown Court Compendium summarises this as “no inference may be drawn unless D was given the opportunity to consult a solicitor before being questioned or charged” (Crown Court Compendium, 17-1 para 4).

Where disclosure is limited, the important words are “in the circumstances existing at the time”. The Compendium says the object of s.34 “is to deter late fabrication and to encourage early disclosure of genuine defences” (para 2), and that an adverse inference “will only be appropriate where the jury concludes that the silence can only sensibly be attributed to D not having an answer, or none that would withstand questioning” (para 12). On legal advice it says: “Ds often cite advice from a legal representative as the reason for remaining silent in the face of questioning: like any other reason…, this is for the jury to examine” (para 13) (Crown Court Compendium, 17-1).

So thin disclosure does not automatically protect a client from an inference. It is a circumstance the court can weigh. That is why the adviser should record what was (and was not) disclosed and the reasons for the advice given.

Prepared statements. The Compendium notes that where a prepared statement is given, “no inference is available unless D later relies on facts which do not appear in the prepared statement” (Crown Court Compendium, 17-1 para 6).

If disclosure is inadequate

Code C does not entitle the suspect to full disclosure before interview: beyond the Note 11ZA minimum, paragraph 11.1A leaves the decision to the investigating officer. Practice steps that stay within Code C:

  • Ask the officer to explain what can and cannot be disclosed, and write down the answer
  • Check that the officer has recorded what was disclosed and when, as para 11.1A requires
  • If the issue is the lawfulness of arrest or detention, ask the custody officer about documents under para 3.4(b)
  • Ask to see the custody record (para 2.4), including the recorded grounds for arrest and detention
  • Take the client’s instructions, advise on the information actually available, and record the advice and the reasons for it

The adviser may want to say on the interview record, briefly and without giving evidence, that the advice has been given on the basis of the limited information disclosed. Note 6D says unacceptable conduct includes “answering questions on a suspect’s behalf or providing written replies for the suspect to quote” (Code C, Note 6D), so any statement should be about the advice, not the facts.

After interview: pre-charge engagement

Annex B of the Attorney General’s Guidelines on Disclosure (2024) covers discussions “at any time after the first PACE interview, up until the commencement of criminal proceedings” (para 1). Pre-charge engagement means “voluntary engagement between the parties to an investigation after the first PACE interview, and before any suspect has been formally charged. Pre-charge engagement is a voluntary process and it may be terminated at any time” (para 3). The Standard Crime Contract 2025 Specification defines it in matching terms as “voluntary engagement on disclosure which has been (either formally or informally) agreed by all parties to an investigation” that “takes place after the first PACE interview, and before any suspect has been formally charged” (Specification v3, para 1.2).

Annex B paragraph 4 lists examples, including “Giving the suspect the opportunity to comment on any proposed further lines of inquiry”, “Agreeing any key word searches of digital material that the suspect would like carried out” and “The suspect identifying and providing contact details of any potential witnesses”. It “may take place whenever it is agreed between the parties that it may assist the investigation” (para 6), and “A no comment interview does not preclude the possibility of pre-charge engagement” (para 9).

On silence, Annex B says “adverse inferences under section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 are not available at trial where a suspect failed to mention a fact when asked about a matter in pre-charge engagement” and “An adverse inference may only be drawn where the suspect failed to mention a fact while being questioned under caution by a constable” (para 7), reflecting the words of s.34(1)(a). And “Should a defendant choose not to engage at this stage, that decision should not be held against him at a later stage in the proceedings” (para 3).

Disclosure is part of the process: “the statutory disclosure rules will not be engaged. However, disclosure of unused material must be considered as part of the pre-charge engagement process, to ensure that the discussions are fair and that the suspect is not misled as to the strength of the prosecution case” (para 22). Annex B also says “a written record should always be made and kept” (para 20).

For legal aid, the Specification treats this as separate work: the definition of the Police Station Attendance Fixed Fee in paragraph 1.2 says it “does not include Advice and Assistance to a Client who has entered into Pre-Charge Engagement on disclosure”, and paragraph 9.109 provides a separate Unit of Work that “covers Advice and Assistance to a Client on Pre-Charge Engagement only” (Specification v3).

After charge: CPIA and common law disclosure

The statutory scheme is Part I of the CPIA 1996. For a summary offence, for example, it applies where the accused “pleads not guilty” (s.1(1)(a)). The prosecutor must then “disclose to the accused any prosecution material which has not previously been disclosed to the accused and which might reasonably be considered capable of undermining the case for the prosecution against the accused or of assisting the case for the accused” (CPIA 1996, s.3(1)(a)). The Attorney General’s Guidelines say the statutory duty “applies from the point of a not guilty plea in the magistrates’ court and from the point a case is sent to the Crown Court” (AG Guidelines, para 78). The Notice of Rights tells detainees: “If you are charged with an offence, you or your solicitor must be allowed to see the evidence against you as well as evidence which may help your defence. This must be done before your trial starts” (Notice of Rights, section 11).

Before that, common law duties apply. The Guidelines say they “apply at all stages of a case, from charge to sentence and post-conviction” and give examples including “material which would assist in the making of a bail application” (AG Guidelines, paras 78–79). The CPS Disclosure Manual describes this as “common law disclosure”, where “a prosecutor should consider whether justice and fairness require any immediate disclosure in the particular circumstances of the case”, and lists “any previous convictions of the victim or a key witness if that information could reasonably be expected to assist the accused when applying for bail” as an example (CPS Disclosure Manual, chapter 2). It adds that disclosure “prior to the statutory duty arising will not exceed the disclosure which would be required under the CPIA”.

Worked example (invented)

Invented scenario for illustration only. It is not a real case.

A client is arrested for theft from a shop. The officer’s first briefing is one line: “theft, Tuesday”. The representative asks for the time and place, what the client is said to have done, and whether there is CCTV or a witness account, referring to the Note 11ZA minimum.

The officer adds the store, the time, that a security guard says the client left with two items without paying, and that CCTV has been requested but not yet viewed. The representative notes exactly what was said and when, asks to see the custody record (para 2.4), and checks whether any comment on arrest will be put as a significant statement (para 11.4).

The representative then takes instructions in private and advises on the information available, recording the reasons for the advice. If the CCTV is later viewed and new material emerges, that may justify a further interview or pre-charge engagement.

FAQs

Are the police required to show me all their evidence before interview?

No. PACE Code C paragraph 11.1A requires sufficient information for you to understand the nature of the offence and why you are suspected of it, but it “does not require the disclosure of details at a time which might prejudice the criminal investigation”. What is disclosed is decided by the investigating officer, who must record what was disclosed and when.

What is the least the police must tell me?

Note 11ZA of Code C says what is sufficient depends on the case but should normally include, as a minimum, “a description of the facts relating to the suspected offence that are known to the officer, including the time and place in question”.

Does this apply if I do not have a solicitor?

Yes. Note 11ZA says the requirement applies before interview “whether or not they are legally represented”. For voluntary interviews, Code C paragraph 3.21A(a) says it applies whether or not you ask for legal advice.

Can I see my custody record?

Your solicitor and appropriate adult must be allowed to inspect the whole custody record while you are detained (Code C 2.4). After you leave, you, your legal representative or appropriate adult can ask for a copy, and that entitlement lasts for 12 months after release (Code C 2.4A).

If the police disclose very little, can my silence still be used against me?

Possibly. Section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 allows a court or jury to draw proper inferences if you fail to mention a fact you later rely on and could reasonably have been expected to mention at the time. The Crown Court Compendium (chapter 17-1, para 10) says this “may depend upon a variety of factors which, usually, should be left for the jury to determine”, and quotes the Court of Appeal in Argent that “knowledge, personality and legal advice are all part of the relevant circumstances”. Limited disclosure does not automatically prevent an inference, so the reasons for any advice should be recorded.

What is pre-charge engagement?

Under Annex B of the Attorney General’s Guidelines on Disclosure it is voluntary engagement between the parties after the first PACE interview and before charge, for example about further lines of inquiry. It is not a further interview, and the Guidelines say section 34 inferences are not available for failing to mention a fact during pre-charge engagement.

What is the difference between police station disclosure and CPIA disclosure?

Police station disclosure under Code C supports advice before interview. The statutory prosecution disclosure duty under Part I of the Criminal Procedure and Investigations Act 1996 applies once proceedings are under way; the Attorney General’s Guidelines say it applies from a not guilty plea in the magistrates’ court and from the point a case is sent to the Crown Court, with common law duties applying from charge.

Sources

Each point above is quoted from the source named next to it. Last reviewed: 29 October 2026.

Sources & further reading

Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.

Need help?

Find an accredited police station representative, or contact us.