Reading Police Disclosure: What To Look For

How to analyse police disclosure, spot the weak points in their case and decide on interview strategy.

At The StationIntermediate✓ Fact-Checked588 words0 viewsUpdated 15 October 2026

Reading Police Disclosure: What To Look For

Pre-interview disclosure is the basis of your advice. Usually it's a short written summary from the officer in the case, sometimes with some statements, CCTV stills or BWV. Your job is to get as much as you reasonably can, read it critically, and work out what it tells you, and what it doesn't.

What you're entitled to

There's no right to full disclosure before interview. But the suspect must be given enough information to understand the nature of the offence and why they're suspected (Code C 11.1A), and in a voluntary interview the same right applies (3.21A). Beyond that, it's the officer's choice.

That choice has consequences. Inadequate disclosure can be a good reason for advising silence (R v Imran and Hussain [1997] Crim LR 754). And the police mustn't mislead you about the evidence: in R v Mason [1988] 1 WLR 139, a confession was excluded where the police had lied to the solicitor about the evidence.

How to get it

  • Ask for written disclosure, or write down what's said word for word.
  • Ask specific questions:
    • What's the allegation: date, time, place, what's said to have happened?
    • Who are the witnesses? Is there a complainant statement?
    • Is there CCTV, BWV, forensic evidence, phone evidence, or an ID procedure?
    • What did the client say on arrest, in the van, or in custody?
    • Has anything been seized? Have searches been done?
    • Are there co-suspects, and what have they said?
  • Ask what the officer won't tell you, and note that it was withheld.

Reading it critically

What's the actual allegation?

Pin down the elements of the offence. Which ones does the disclosure cover, and which does it leave out (for example intent, dishonesty, or identification)?

Where does the evidence come from?

Is it first-hand or hearsay? One witness or several? Independent or connected to the complainant?

What's missing?

  • Gaps in the timeline
  • CCTV that "is being obtained"
  • No mention of forensic results, which may still be pending
  • Nothing on identification beyond a description

Significant statements

Has the client said anything that the police will put to them as a significant statement (Code C 11.4A)? Find out what it was and when it was said.

Signs of what's coming

Phrases like "further enquiries are ongoing" or "we'll be asking about other matters" can mean the interview will be broader than disclosed. Ask directly.

Turning disclosure into advice

Ask yourself:

  1. On what's been disclosed, is there a case to answer?
  2. Does the client have an account that answers it?
  3. What's the risk if they answer questions, and the risk if they don't (adverse inference)?
  4. Is the disclosure enough for them to give a safe account at all?

Then decide between an account, a prepared statement, or no comment. Explain the reasons to the client, and record them.

Record it

Note the disclosure, who gave it, when, and what was refused. If you advise no comment because of limited disclosure, say so in the interview at the start. The record of reasons is what lets a court assess later whether reliance on your advice was reasonable.

Sources


General information only.

Sources & further reading

Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.