The Police Caution Explained: Your Rights When Arrested
"Caution" means two different things in criminal law. This page is about the words of the caution: the warning given on arrest and before interview. (For the out-of-court disposal, see Police Cautions in England.)
The words
Under PACE Code C para 10.5, the standard caution is:
"You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence."
It must be given on arrest, and before a suspect is questioned about their involvement in an offence (Code C 10.1). Minor deviations don't matter as long as the sense is kept.
What each part means
"You do not have to say anything." The right to silence. No one can be made to answer police questions in interview.
"But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court." This is the warning about adverse inferences under s.34 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994. If the person later relies in their defence on a fact they didn't mention in interview, and they could reasonably have been expected to mention it then, the court or jury may draw an inference from that.
"Anything you do say may be given in evidence." What's said in interview, on arrest, and in the van can all be used.
When no inference can be drawn
- Before legal advice: no inference under s.34 can be drawn if the person was at an authorised place of detention and hadn't been allowed an opportunity to consult a solicitor before being questioned (s.34(2A)). In those cases, the restricted caution in Code C Annex C applies: "You do not have to say anything, but anything you do say may be given in evidence."
- On its own: no one can be convicted solely on an inference from silence (s.38(3)).
How the courts approach s.34
The leading cases include:
- R v Argent [1997] 2 Cr App R 27: the conditions for drawing an inference, including that the fact relied on was one the defendant could reasonably have been expected to mention, judged by reference to the defendant and the circumstances at the time.
- R v Condron [1997] 1 WLR 827: silence on legal advice. The jury must be properly directed, and advice to remain silent doesn't automatically prevent an inference.
- R v Beckles [2005] 1 Cr App R 23 and R v Howell [2005] 1 Cr App R 1: where the defendant says they stayed silent on legal advice, the question is whether they genuinely and reasonably relied on it. Good reasons, such as inadequate disclosure, need to be recorded.
Special warnings: ss.36 and 37
These are separate from s.34. If a person under arrest fails or refuses to account for:
- an object, substance or mark on them, in their possession or at the place of arrest (s.36), or
- their presence at a place at about the time of the offence (s.37),
the court may draw an inference, but only if the officer first gave a special warning in ordinary language (Code C 10.10–10.11). It must cover what offence is being investigated, what fact they're being asked to account for, and the consequences of not doing so. Make sure the warning is given properly and recorded.
What this means for advice
The caution isn't an instruction to talk. It's a warning about the consequences of not doing so. The decision on whether to answer questions, give a prepared statement or say nothing is made after disclosure and a private consultation. It depends on:
- How much the police have disclosed
- The strength of the evidence
- The client's account, and whether they're fit to give it
- The risk of an inference, against the risk of saying something harmful
Record the advice and the reasons for it. If the case goes to trial, they may matter.
For clients
You're entitled to free legal advice before any interview. Ask for it. Don't discuss the case with officers outside the interview room. If you don't understand the caution, say so, and the officer must explain it.
Sources
- PACE Code C 2023, paras 10.1–10.11 and Annex C (GOV.UK)
- Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, ss.34–38 (legislation.gov.uk)
General information only. Checked 15 October 2026.