Mental Health and Vulnerability in Custody
A lot of the people you'll see in custody have mental health problems, learning disabilities, autism, or other conditions that affect how they understand and cope with what's happening. Spotting vulnerability, and making sure the safeguards actually happen, is one of the most important things a rep does.
Who counts as "vulnerable"
Under Code C 1.13(d), a person is vulnerable if, because of a mental health condition or mental disorder, they:
- may have difficulty understanding or communicating effectively about the full implications of what's happening, including their rights
- don't appear to understand the significance of what they're told, of questions put to them, or of their replies
- appear particularly prone to becoming confused, giving unreliable or incriminating information without realising it, or accepting suggestions to end the questioning
If an officer has any reason to suspect a person may be vulnerable, they must be treated as vulnerable, in the absence of clear evidence otherwise (1.4). A formal diagnosis isn't required. Note 1G makes the point that someone with no known condition may still be vulnerable. The officer has to consider the 1.13(d) factors case by case.
What follows when someone is vulnerable
- An appropriate adult must be called and asked to attend (3.15). For a vulnerable adult, the AA can be a relative or carer, someone experienced with people with mental health conditions, or another responsible adult not connected with the police (1.7(b)).
- No interview without the AA, except in urgent cases authorised by a superintendent (11.15, 11.18).
- The AA can ask for a solicitor on the person's behalf (6.5A).
- Healthcare: the custody officer must make sure clinical attention is given where needed (Code C section 9). A healthcare professional may be asked to assess fitness for detention and interview (Annex G).
Code C Annex E summarises the provisions for vulnerable people.
Signs to look for
- History or mention of mental health services, medication or hospital admission
- Difficulty following simple explanations, or answers that don't fit the question
- Very quick agreement with everything said
- Distress, agitation, withdrawal, or responding to things you can't see or hear
- Reading or writing difficulties, special educational needs, or a learning disability
- The custody risk assessment or a liaison and diversion referral
Ask open questions. Check the custody record and ask the custody officer what's known. Many forces have liaison and diversion services that can assess people in custody. Ask whether they've been involved.
Section 136 and police stations
The Mental Health Act 1983 s.136 allows police to remove someone from a public place to a place of safety. Since the Policing and Crime Act 2017, a police station can't be used as a place of safety for anyone under 18, and can only be used for adults in limited circumstances set out in regulations (MHA s.136A). If your client was detained under s.136 and then arrested, find out exactly what happened and when.
Advising a vulnerable client
- Allow more time, and use plain words.
- Check understanding by asking the client to explain the advice back.
- Consider whether they're fit to be interviewed at all. See Fitness for interview.
- Think carefully before advising an account where the client is suggestible. A prepared statement may be safer.
- Make sure the AA is present, understands their role, and doesn't answer for the client.
Record it
Note the signs you saw, what you asked for (AA, healthcare assessment, delay), the response, and the time. If vulnerability wasn't recognised and an interview went ahead, the record will matter later.
Sources
- PACE Code C 2023 (GOV.UK): paras 1.4, 1.7, 1.13(d), 3.15, 6.5A, 9, 11.15–11.18, Annexes E and G
- Mental Health Act 1983, ss.136 and 136A (legislation.gov.uk)
General information only.