Police Cautions in England: Understanding the Types and Consequences
A caution is a formal out-of-court disposal. It isn't a conviction, but it is a criminal record. Clients are often offered one at the end of an interview and want an instant answer. They should get proper advice first.
The types of caution in force now
Simple caution (adults)
A formal warning for an adult who admits the offence, where there's enough evidence to prosecute, and who agrees to be cautioned. It's governed by Ministry of Justice guidance. There are statutory restrictions on simple cautions for indictable-only offences and for some either-way offences (Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, s.17).
Conditional caution (adults)
A caution with conditions attached, such as rehabilitation, reparation or a financial penalty. It's made under the Criminal Justice Act 2003, Part 3 (ss.22–27). If the conditions aren't met, the person can be prosecuted for the original offence.
Youth caution and youth conditional caution (under 18)
These are the youth equivalents, under the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (ss.66ZA and 66A).
Community resolution
A non-statutory, informal outcome, usually for minor offences where the victim agrees. It isn't a caution, but it's recorded locally by the police.
Note: the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 provides for new "diversionary" and "community" cautions to replace the current adult cautions. As of October 2026, those provisions (Part 6) are not in force, according to the government's commencement schedule. Check before relying on either regime.
The conditions for any caution
- An admission of the offence. Silence or a no comment interview isn't enough.
- Sufficient evidence to prosecute.
- The person must consent, having been told what a caution means.
This is why an offer of a caution has to be thought about before or during interview. A client who goes no comment can't then be cautioned without an admission.
Consequences
Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974
- A simple caution (adult or youth) is spent immediately.
- A conditional caution is spent after three months, or earlier if it stops having effect.
Once spent, it doesn't usually need to be declared, for example to most employers or insurers.
DBS checks
- Basic checks show only unspent convictions and conditional cautions.
- Standard and enhanced checks follow the filtering rules. An adult caution for a non-specified offence is disclosed if it's less than 6 years old. A caution for a specified offence (a list of serious and safeguarding-related offences) is always disclosed. Youth cautions aren't automatically disclosed (youth conditional cautions are the exception). Unspent conditional cautions are always disclosed.
Travel and work
Some countries' visa and entry forms ask about arrests or cautions, not just convictions. Some professions and regulators require disclosure. Clients in regulated jobs (healthcare, teaching, finance, law) should check their regulator's rules before accepting.
Advising on a caution offer
- Is there actually sufficient evidence? If not, why accept?
- Is there a defence? A caution needs an admission, so the client must genuinely accept they committed the offence.
- What are the realistic alternatives (NFA, charge)?
- What will it mean for this client's job, immigration status, travel or regulator?
- Get the exact offence and type of caution in writing before the client signs.
Never let a client admit an offence just to get out of the station. If they don't accept guilt, they shouldn't accept a caution.
Sources
- Criminal Justice Act 2003, Part 3 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015, s.17 (legislation.gov.uk)
- PCSC Act 2022 commencement schedule (GOV.UK)
- DBS filtering guide (GOV.UK)
- Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, Schedule 2 (legislation.gov.uk)
General information only. Checked 15 October 2026.