Common Problems at Police Stations & How to Solve Them
Things go wrong at the station all the time. Here are fifteen common problems and a practical way through each, with the Code C provision to point to where there is one.
Access and timing
1. You're kept waiting to see the client. Ask politely for a time estimate, and ask for your arrival time to be noted. If the delay is unreasonable, escalate to the custody sergeant. (Code C 6.1, 6.6)
2. The police want to interview before you've finished advising. Say you haven't finished, give a realistic time, and don't start until you're ready. A detainee who wants legal advice "may not be interviewed or continue to be interviewed until they have received such advice" unless one of the exceptions in Code C 6.6 applies. Examples are delay authorised by a superintendent under Annex B, or the detainee changing their mind (6.6(a)–(d)). If the police say an exception applies, ask for the authorising officer and the grounds to be recorded. (6.6)
3. You're refused the custody record. Point out that the solicitor must be allowed to inspect the whole record (2.4). Escalate if needed.
4. You're running late. Phone custody and the OIC, give an honest ETA, and ask them not to start without you. Tell the firm.
Client issues
5. The client is drunk, high or unwell. Ask for a healthcare assessment, and ask for the interview to wait until they're fit. (Annex G; 11.18(b))
6. The client seems vulnerable but no AA has been called. Raise it with the custody officer straight away. An officer who has any reason to suspect vulnerability must treat the person as vulnerable. (1.4, 3.15)
7. The client admits the offence to you but wants to deny it in interview. You can't help them give an account you know is false. You can advise no comment, explain the options (including the effect of an admission on a later guilty plea), and continue to act. If they insist on putting forward a false account, you may have to withdraw. Speak to your supervisor.
8. The client won't take your advice. Explain the risks clearly, record your advice and their decision, and have them sign it if possible. It's their decision.
9. The client becomes aggressive towards you. End the consultation and leave the room if you feel unsafe. Tell custody staff. Your safety comes first.
Interview issues
10. New evidence is produced in interview. Ask for a break to consult with the client. Don't let them answer on the hoof.
11. Questioning becomes oppressive or misleading. Intervene, calmly, on the record. If it continues, ask for a break and raise it with the custody officer.
12. The recording equipment fails. Code E deals with failures. Make sure the failure and what happens next are recorded, and check the client understands any change in arrangements.
13. No interpreter, or a poor one. The interview mustn't go ahead without an interpreter where one is needed, except in urgent cases. Raise concerns about the quality of interpreting at once. (11.18(c); section 13)
Time and detention
14. A review is overdue, or the detention clock is running out. Check the relevant time and review times on the custody record. Raise any missed review with the custody officer and ask for it to be recorded. (PACE ss.40–42)
15. Bail conditions are unreasonable. Make representations to the custody officer, offer realistic alternatives, and tell the client how conditions can be varied later.
The golden rule
Whatever the problem, write it down: what happened, when, who was involved, what you said, and the response. The attendance note is your protection and the client's.
Sources
General information only.