Top 10 Catastrophic Fails at Police Stations (And How to Avoid Them)
These are the mistakes that come back to haunt reps and firms: on file review, in a complaint, or when the trial lawyer reads the attendance note. All of them are avoidable.
1. Advising before getting disclosure
Taking instructions and advising on interview before you know what the police have. Avoid it: get disclosure first, record it word for word, and ask what's been withheld.
2. Not reading the custody record
Missing the arrest time, the necessity ground, a healthcare note, or a significant comment. Avoid it: read the whole record at the start (Code C 2.4) and again before interview.
3. Missing vulnerability
Interviewing a client who should have had an AA, or who wasn't fit. Avoid it: ask about health, medication, learning and communication needs, and act on the answers. (Code C 1.4, 3.15, Annex G)
4. No reasons recorded for no comment
The client goes no comment and nothing in the note explains why. At trial, the court looks at whether reliance on the advice was reasonable. Avoid it: record the reasons at the time, and consider stating them at the start of the interview.
5. A prepared statement that leaves things out
A thin statement, followed by a different or fuller defence at trial, can still lead to an inference. Avoid it: cover every fact the client will rely on, and keep it consistent with their instructions.
6. Letting the client answer "just a few"
Selective answering often does more damage than either a full account or no comment. Avoid it: agree the approach with the client in advance and help them stick to it.
7. Staying silent in interview
Not intervening when questions are unfair, misleading or oppressive, or when new evidence is produced. Avoid it: intervene calmly on the record, and ask for a break to take instructions.
8. Saying too much to the police
Chatting with officers about the client's position, or "off the record" views. Avoid it: be polite, but say nothing about instructions or advice.
9. Poor handover to the firm
An attendance note that's late, illegible or missing the key facts: outcome, bail dates, conditions, next steps. Avoid it: send a clear, complete note promptly, the same day where possible.
10. Getting the billing basics wrong
Missing times, splitting one investigation into two claims, or claiming travel on top of the fixed fee. Avoid it: record all times accurately, and follow the firm's billing guidance. See Claiming Your Fees.
The common thread
Almost every fail comes down to not checking or not recording. Slow down at the start, read everything, and write it all down.
General information only.