Client Management: Difficult Clients and Awkward Situations

Handling hard clients: the hostile, the confused, the time-wasters and those who won’t take advice.

Client ManagementAdvanced✓ Fact-Checked611 words1 viewsUpdated 11 November 2026

Client Management: Difficult Clients and Awkward Situations

Some clients are hard work: hostile, confused, rude, or determined to ignore your advice. You still have to advise them properly. Here's how to handle the common difficult situations.

The hostile client

They may be angry at the police, at being arrested, or at you for "being on their side". Stay calm. Explain who you are and that you're independent of the police. Don't argue back. If they're threatening or you feel unsafe, end the consultation and tell custody staff.

The client who won't talk to you

Explain why you need instructions: you can't advise them properly without knowing their side. Make clear what they tell you is confidential (SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 6.3: you keep clients' affairs confidential "unless disclosure is required or permitted by law or the client consents"). If they still won't engage, give advice on what you know, record it, and record that they declined to give instructions.

The client who won't take advice

Explain the risks clearly and simply. Check they understand. It's their choice. Record your advice and their decision, and ask them to sign your note if possible.

The client who wants to lie

If the client tells you they did it but wants to deny it in interview, you can't help them put forward an account you know to be false. You can:

  • advise them on no comment
  • explain the effect an admission may have on credit for a guilty plea later
  • keep acting, as long as you don't mislead anyone (SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 1.4)

If they insist on giving a false account, you may need to stop acting. Speak to your supervisor.

The client who wants you to contact someone

You may be asked to call a partner, employer or friend. Be careful. You must not pass messages that could interfere with witnesses or the investigation, and the police may have restricted contact (for example, by delaying the right to have someone informed under PACE s.56, which is only allowed for an indictable offence, on the authority of an inspector or above, and for no more than 36 hours from the relevant time: s.56(2)–(3); Code C, Annex B). If in doubt, decline and explain why.

The intoxicated or unwell client

They may not be fit to be advised properly, let alone interviewed. Ask for a healthcare assessment, and ask for the interview to be delayed until they're fit. See Fitness for interview.

The client who wants to plead to "get out"

Clients sometimes want to admit everything just to go home. Make sure they understand what an admission, a caution or a charge would mean for them. Don't let the custody clock drive a decision they'll regret.

Co-suspects

If you're asked to advise two people in the same matter, check for a conflict first (SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, para 6.2; PACE Code C, Note 6G: "Any question of a conflict of interest is for the solicitor under their professional code of conduct"). If their interests diverge (for example, one blames the other), you can only act for one.

Protect yourself

Write everything down at the time. A clear record of what you advised, what the client said, and what they chose to do is your best protection if a complaint follows.

Sources

SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs (https://www.sra.org.uk/solicitors/standards-regulations/code-conduct-solicitors/), paras 1.4, 6.2 and 6.3. PACE 1984, s.56 (https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1984/60/section/56). PACE Code C 2023 (https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/pace-code-c-2023), para 12.3 (fitness for interview), Annex B and Notes 6D, 6G and 6J. General information only.

Sources & further reading

Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.