Understanding Legal Aid: Eligibility, Application & Common Issues
Clients ask about legal aid at the police station all the time. "Do I have to pay for you?" "Will I get legal aid at court?" This is a plain guide to the answers, for reps and for clients.
At the police station: free, whatever your means
Anyone arrested and held in custody at a police station, or attending voluntarily for interview, is entitled to free legal advice. There's no means test for this advice. For people in custody it's provided under s.13 of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012. For voluntary interviews it's provided as police station advice and assistance under the Standard Crime Contract. The right to consult a solicitor is in PACE s.58 and Code C section 6.
The client can ask for their own solicitor or the duty solicitor. Either way, the request goes through the Defence Solicitor Call Centre (DSCC), and the advice is free.
Tell clients this plainly. Some decline advice because they think they'll be billed.
At the magistrates' court
Legal aid for representation at court ("a representation order") depends on two tests.
The interests of justice test
The LAA considers the factors set out in LASPO s.17(2), including whether the client is likely to lose their liberty or livelihood or suffer serious damage to their reputation, whether the case involves a substantial question of law, whether the client can understand the proceedings or put their own case, whether witnesses need to be traced, interviewed or cross-examined by an expert, and whether representation is in someone else's interests (for example, to avoid the client cross-examining a witness personally).
The means test
Most adults are means tested. Some pass automatically, including under-18s and people on certain passported benefits. Thresholds change, so check the LAA's current figures rather than quoting from memory.
In the Crown Court
Cases sent to the Crown Court automatically satisfy the interests of justice test. The means test is different: there's an upper income limit, and some defendants have to pay contributions from income and, if convicted, from capital.
Applying
The application for a representation order is made online through the LAA's criminal legal aid application service, usually by the solicitor after charge. The client will need evidence of income and benefits.
Common problems
- Missing evidence of means. The application stalls and the first hearing goes ahead without an order. Tell clients at the station what they'll need to bring.
- Self-employed clients. Their means evidence is more complicated, so start early.
- Interests of justice refused. For low-level matters, a refusal can be challenged with more detail on the IoJ factors.
- Wrong assumption about the station. Clients think the station is means tested. It isn't.
What the rep should say
"Advice here is free. It doesn't depend on your income. If you're charged, whether you get legal aid at court depends on the case and your finances. The firm will help you apply, so bring proof of income and any benefits."
Sources
- LASPO 2012, ss.13–17 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Criminal legal aid: means testing (GOV.UK)
- Legal aid (GOV.UK)
General information only. Eligibility rules and thresholds change; check current LAA guidance.