What Happens in a Police Interview Under Caution?
How recorded police interviews work in England and Wales: the caution, PACE rights, the interview itself, what the rep does and the main options on how to approach it. General information, not legal advice.
Last updated: 2 November 2026 · Author: Robert Cashman, Duty Solicitor & Higher Court Advocate
If someone is in custody now
Ask the custody officer for the duty solicitor immediately. Legal advice at the police station is free in most cases and confidential. Do not rely on this page for live tactical decisions.
Who this guide is for
Suspects and family members wanting to understand the process; trainee and accredited police station representatives; criminal defence solicitors and paralegals. It complements our beginner's guide and disclosure guide.
When interviews under caution happen
A person is interviewed "under caution" when they are suspected of an offence and police intend to ask questions about it. This usually happens after arrest and detention in a custody suite, or at a voluntary attendance where the same caution applies. The interview must comply with PACE Code C (detention, treatment, and questioning).
If you have requested legal advice, interview should not normally begin until you have had a reasonable opportunity to consult your solicitor or representative in private — and, in practice, after your adviser has taken disclosure from the investigating officer.
The police caution
“You do not have to say anything. But it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court. Anything you do say may be given in evidence.”
The caution is given before questioning. In plain terms it has three parts:
- You do not have to say anything — silence is a legal choice; you cannot be forced to answer.
- But it may harm your defence… — if you later rely in court on a fact you did not mention when questioned, a court may draw an adverse inference in certain circumstances (see below).
- Anything you do say may be given in evidence — answers are recorded and may be played to a court whether they help or hurt your case.
Silence and adverse inference
Silence is not an admission of guilt. However, section 34 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 allows the court or jury in certain circumstances to draw an inference when a defendant fails to mention a fact when questioned under caution that they later rely on in their defence. It only applies to a fact “which in the circumstances existing at the time the accused could reasonably have been expected to mention” (s.34(1)). The caution in PACE Code C, paragraph 10.5 puts it this way: “it may harm your defence if you do not mention when questioned something which you later rely on in Court”.
That is why representatives weigh disclosure, strength of evidence, and your instructions before advising answer, no comment, or a prepared statement. Poor disclosure can support a no-comment strategy — see our police disclosure guide.
What happens step by step
- 1
Recording begins
The interview is audio-recorded and may be video-recorded. The interviewer gives their name and rank and asks you and anyone else present (for example your solicitor or an appropriate adult) to identify themselves (PACE Code E, paragraph 3.4). If you asked for legal advice, that request will already be in the custody record (PACE s.58(2)).
- 2
Caution given and understood
The interviewing officer reads the caution. If it appears you do not understand it, the officer should explain it in their own words (Code C, Note 10D). If you do not speak English well, an interpreter should be used. Your representative can ask for the caution to be explained again if needed.
- 3
Questions about the allegation
Police put their account and ask questions. You may answer, decline to answer some or all questions, or read a prepared statement and then answer "no comment" to further questions. Your representative does not answer for you but can intervene on improper questioning.
- 4
Representative interventions
Your rep may interrupt if questions are oppressive, misleading, or outside proper disclosure; request breaks for consultation; raise welfare or vulnerability issues; or ask for clarification. PACE Code C sets standards for breaks and consultation.
- 5
Closing the interview
You are usually asked whether you wish to add or clarify anything. What you say at this stage is still under caution and on the recording.
- 6
Recording sealed
If the interview was recorded on removable media (discs or tapes), the master recording is sealed in your presence. Most interviews are now recorded on a secure digital network, where nothing is sealed and access to the file is restricted. You will be given a copy of the recording if you are charged or told you will be prosecuted; otherwise only "as agreed with the police or on the order of a court" (PACE Code E, paragraphs 3.1 and 3.4(e)). Your firm keeps attendance notes; the recording may become evidence if the case proceeds.
Your rights in interview
Right to silence
You cannot be forced to answer police questions. The caution makes clear that silence is a legal choice — but see the section on adverse inference below.
Right to free legal advice
Under PACE s.58 and Code C, you can consult a solicitor or accredited representative in private before and during interview. In most police station cases this is funded by legal aid without charge to you.
Right to breaks
Code C provides for rest, refreshment, and further consultation with your adviser — short refreshment breaks at approximately two-hour intervals, and breaks at recognised meal times (Code C, paragraph 12.8). Breaks are not unlimited, but you must be treated humanely and given reasonable opportunities to consult in private.
Right to understand the process
You have the right to consult the PACE Codes of Practice (Code C, paragraph 3.1(a)(iii)). Before interview, you and your solicitor must be given "sufficient information to enable them to understand the nature of any such offence, and why they are suspected of committing it" (Code C, paragraph 11.1A). That is a minimum, not full disclosure of the evidence.
What your representative does in interview
- Sits with you throughout the recorded interview
- Takes a note of questions and your answers
- Intervenes if questions are improper, oppressive, or outside fair disclosure
- Requests breaks so you can consult in private
- Raises PACE and welfare issues (interpreter, appropriate adult, fitness)
- Can read a prepared statement on your behalf if that is the agreed strategy
The representative does not answer questions for you. Their job is to protect your rights and support the strategy agreed in private consultation.
Answer, silence, or prepared statement
There is no single correct approach for every case. Your representative's advice depends on disclosure, evidence, and your instructions.
Answer questions
You give a full account in response to police questions.
Often considered when: Often considered when disclosure is adequate, the account is straightforward, and your representative assesses that answering will not harm the defence.
No comment
You exercise your right to silence for some or all questions.
Often considered when: Often considered when disclosure is poor, the allegation is serious and the evidence picture unclear, or answering risks inconsistent or incomplete accounts. Silence is not a "trick" — it is a strategic choice with potential adverse-inference consequences that your rep should explain.
Prepared statement
Your representative reads a written statement setting out your account; you then answer "no comment" to further questions.
Often considered when: Often used to put a controlled account on the record while avoiding detailed questioning on matters not yet disclosed. The statement itself can be used in evidence.
After the interview
The police decide next steps: release without charge, bail (with or without conditions), or charge. Further interviews may follow if new evidence emerges. Your representative's attendance note and the sealed recording form part of the case file. If you are charged, the matter moves to the magistrates' or Crown Court and CPIA disclosure obligations continue through your defence firm.
Frequently asked questions
Can the police interview me without a solicitor?+
If you have asked for legal advice, you may not be interviewed until you have received it, unless one of the limited exceptions in PACE Code C, paragraph 6.6 applies — for example, a delay authorised by a superintendent under Annex B, or your chosen solicitor cannot be contacted or declines to attend and you then decline the duty solicitor. If you decline advice, you may be interviewed without a rep, but the caution still applies.
Will silence make me look guilty?+
Silence cannot be treated as proof of guilt on its own. However, in certain circumstances a court may draw an adverse inference if you fail to mention something when questioned that you later rely on at trial. Your representative should explain how this applies to your case.
Can my representative tell the police what I said in consultation?+
No. Consultation is legally privileged. Your rep cannot disclose your instructions without your consent.
What if I was not cautioned properly?+
The validity and use of answers may depend on whether the caution was given and understood. This is a technical area — your representative or solicitor will advise if there is a challenge to admissibility.
Related guides
Police disclosure guide
What the police should tell your rep before interview
Beginner's guide
Full custody lifecycle from arrest to charge or release
PACE Codes
Code C — detention, treatment, and questioning
Wiki: no-comment interviews
Rep-focused practice notes
Common offences guide
Elements, defences, and sentencing links
Find a rep
Accredited representatives across England & Wales
Sources & further reading
Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.
Need help at the police station?
Find an accredited representative or contact us — general information only, not legal advice.