No Comment Interviews: When and How
A practical summary for reps: what the law says, when to advise no comment, and how to run it. For a fuller strategy guide, see Mastering the No Comment Interview Strategy.
The law in four points
- Everyone has the right to silence in interview.
- Under s.34 CJPOA 1994, a court may draw an inference if the defendant later relies on a fact they could reasonably have mentioned in interview but didn't.
- No inference can be drawn under s.34 if the person hadn't been allowed to consult a solicitor before questioning at the police station (s.34(2A)).
- No one can be convicted solely on an inference (s.38(3)).
Three options
| Option | When it fits | Main risk |
|---|---|---|
| Full account | Clear defence, enough disclosure, client fit and credible | Inconsistencies; answers used against them |
| Prepared statement, then no comment | Client has a defence but shouldn't face questioning | Facts left out can still attract s.34 (R v Knight [2003] EWCA Crim 1977) |
| No comment | Poor disclosure, unfit client, no account to give | Inference if a defence is raised later |
How to do it
Before the interview
- Get and record disclosure.
- Take instructions privately.
- Advise, giving reasons, and record the client's decision.
- If you're using a prepared statement, draft it with the client. Keep it factual, cover the facts they'll rely on, and have them sign it.
At the start of the interview
- Confirm the client has had legal advice.
- Briefly state the advice and reasons, if appropriate.
- Hand over or read the prepared statement, if there is one.
During it
- The client answers "no comment" to each question.
- Intervene if questions are unfair, oppressive or misleading, or if new material is put without notice.
- Ask for a break if needed.
After it
- Note the questions that mattered, especially ones about facts the client may rely on later.
- Consider whether a further prepared statement is needed if new evidence emerged.
Common mistakes
- Advising no comment by default, without thinking about whether the client has a defence they should put forward now
- Letting the client drift into answering "just the easy ones"
- Not recording the reasons for the advice
- Prepared statements that are too thin, or that contradict what the client will say later
Sources
- CJPOA 1994, ss.34 and 38 (legislation.gov.uk)
- PACE Code C 2023 (GOV.UK): para 10.5 (the caution) and Annex C
General information only.