No Comment Interviews: When and How

Advising on no comment interviews: section 34, prepared statements and when silence helps.

Interview TechniquesIntermediate✓ Fact-Checked434 words0 viewsUpdated 15 October 2026

No Comment Interviews: When and How

A practical summary for reps: what the law says, when to advise no comment, and how to run it. For a fuller strategy guide, see Mastering the No Comment Interview Strategy.

The law in four points

  1. Everyone has the right to silence in interview.
  2. Under s.34 CJPOA 1994, a court may draw an inference if the defendant later relies on a fact they could reasonably have mentioned in interview but didn't.
  3. No inference can be drawn under s.34 if the person hadn't been allowed to consult a solicitor before questioning at the police station (s.34(2A)).
  4. No one can be convicted solely on an inference (s.38(3)).

Three options

Option When it fits Main risk
Full account Clear defence, enough disclosure, client fit and credible Inconsistencies; answers used against them
Prepared statement, then no comment Client has a defence but shouldn't face questioning Facts left out can still attract s.34 (R v Knight [2003] EWCA Crim 1977)
No comment Poor disclosure, unfit client, no account to give Inference if a defence is raised later

How to do it

Before the interview

  • Get and record disclosure.
  • Take instructions privately.
  • Advise, giving reasons, and record the client's decision.
  • If you're using a prepared statement, draft it with the client. Keep it factual, cover the facts they'll rely on, and have them sign it.

At the start of the interview

  • Confirm the client has had legal advice.
  • Briefly state the advice and reasons, if appropriate.
  • Hand over or read the prepared statement, if there is one.

During it

  • The client answers "no comment" to each question.
  • Intervene if questions are unfair, oppressive or misleading, or if new material is put without notice.
  • Ask for a break if needed.

After it

  • Note the questions that mattered, especially ones about facts the client may rely on later.
  • Consider whether a further prepared statement is needed if new evidence emerged.

Common mistakes

  • Advising no comment by default, without thinking about whether the client has a defence they should put forward now
  • Letting the client drift into answering "just the easy ones"
  • Not recording the reasons for the advice
  • Prepared statements that are too thin, or that contradict what the client will say later

Sources


General information only.

Sources & further reading

Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.