Leveson Criminal Courts Review: Government Response 2026

Lord Leveson's two-part review of the criminal courts and the Government's 12 October 2026 response: Bench Division rejected, legal aid and police station changes.

Professional DevelopmentIntermediate✓ Fact-Checked763 words1 viewsUpdated 19 October 2026

The Leveson Criminal Courts Review: What It Means for the Justice System

In December 2024 the government commissioned Sir Brian Leveson, a former President of the Queen's Bench Division, to carry out an Independent Review of the Criminal Courts. The review was prompted by the size of the Crown Court backlog. It was published in two parts:

  • Part 1 (published 9 July 2025): structural reform of the courts
  • Part 2 (published 4 February 2026): efficiency, with 135 recommendations

The Government published its full response on 12 October 2026 (see below).

This page summarises the review at a high level. Read the reports themselves for the detail. A companion page covers the implications for police station work.

Part 1: structure

Part 1 asked how the criminal courts could be reformed so cases are dealt with proportionately, given the pressure on the Crown Court. Its best-known proposal is a new Bench Division of the Crown Court, in which some either-way cases would be tried by a judge sitting with magistrates rather than a jury. Part 1 also made recommendations on allocation of cases between the courts, magistrates' sentencing powers, and greater use of out-of-court resolutions.

The Bench Division was strongly contested by the professions. In its 12 October 2026 response the Government rejected recommendation 30: it had put Bench Division provisions in the Courts and Tribunals Bill but "has subsequently decided to lay an amendment to the Bill to remove the Bench Division provisions". Check the current position of the Bill before advising clients about it.

Part 2: efficiency

Part 2 is about process. According to the government's written statement and published coverage, its recommendations cover:

  • getting decisions right first time at the police and charging stage
  • disclosure
  • listing and the allocation of court time
  • preparation for the first hearing and case management
  • remote participation in hearings
  • technology, including the use of AI
  • the judicial and legal workforce, including legal aid

For defence practitioners, the most discussed proposals include:

  • an option for remote initial legal advice at the police station, not appropriate for under-18s, vulnerable people or indictable-only offences
  • annual reviews of legal aid fees
  • match-funding for the police station and magistrates' court qualifications, and support for training in criminal legal aid firms

Reactions

The Law Society, the Bar Council and the Criminal Bar Association welcomed parts of the review, particularly on the workforce. They objected to others, notably restrictions on jury trial and remote advice to people detained at the police station.

The Government response (12 October 2026)

The Ministry of Justice laid the Government response to the Independent Review of the Criminal Courts (CP 1682) before Parliament on 12 October 2026. It responds to each of the review's 180 recommendations (45 in Part 1 and 135 in Part 2). Points most relevant to defence practitioners:

  • Bench Division rejected (recommendation 30). The Government is removing the Bench Division provisions from the Courts and Tribunals Bill.
  • Video for initial police station advice accepted in principle (recommendation 63): the Government "will make clear" that initial advice allowed by telephone under the 2025 Standard Crime Contract can also be given by video.
  • Charging outcomes sent to defence lawyers and custody reference numbers in DSCC texts accepted in principle (recommendation 64), subject to feasibility.
  • Annual legal aid fee reviews (recommendation 154) and match-funding of the Police Station Qualification and Magistrates' Court Qualification (recommendation 150) accepted in principle, with no committed timetable or funding.

"Accept in principle" means agreement with the aim, not implementation. For the police station detail, see the companion page for reps.

What happens next

Some changes will come through the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which is currently before Parliament (the Government confirmed its return in September 2026). Others need LAA contract changes, guidance or funding decisions. Check the current position before relying on any recommendation as settled.

Official sources


Summary only. Government response checked against the GOV.UK publication on 19 October 2026; earlier sections checked on 15 October 2026. Statistics and quotations from earlier versions of this page have been removed where they couldn't be checked against the reports.

Sources & further reading

Links are to official publishers (legislation, gov.uk, CPS, LAA, Sentencing Council). Case law on this site is limited to entries in our verified case-law registry. Always confirm the current version before relying on it in live advice.