Short answer
The Threshold Test is the exception in the Code for Crown Prosecutors that lets a suspect be charged before the Full Code Test is met. It is for cases where the seriousness or circumstances justify an immediate charging decision and there are substantial grounds to object to bail. All five conditions in section 5 must be met.
Full Code Test vs Threshold Test
| Full Code Test | Threshold Test | |
|---|---|---|
| When used | The normal test for every charging decision (Code, para 4.1) | Only "in limited circumstances, where the Full Code Test is not met" (para 5.1) |
| Evidence | "sufficient evidence to provide a realistic prospect of conviction" (para 4.6) | "reasonable grounds to suspect" now, plus identifiable further evidence expected within a reasonable period (paras 5.3–5.6) |
| Public interest | Must be met (paras 4.9–4.10) | Must be met on the information available at the time (para 5.10) |
| Bail | Not a condition | There must be substantial grounds to object to bail (paras 5.1, 5.9) |
| Review | Continuing review | The Full Code Test "must be applied as soon as the anticipated further evidence or material is received" (para 5.11) |
The Code says: "Prosecutors must only start or continue a prosecution when the case has passed both stages of the Full Code Test. The exception is when the Threshold Test may be applied" (Code for Crown Prosecutors, para 4.1).
All references are to the Code for Crown Prosecutors (eighth edition) and the Director's Guidance on Charging (sixth edition, December 2020), both correct as of 4 November 2026.
When does the Threshold Test apply?
Paragraph 5.1 of the Code says: "In limited circumstances, where the Full Code Test is not met, the Threshold Test may be applied to charge a suspect. The seriousness or circumstances of the case must justify the making of an immediate charging decision, and there must be substantial grounds to object to bail."
The Director's Guidance on Charging puts it the same way. The test is "intended to apply to a very limited range of cases" (para 6.1), and the police "must always endeavour to conclude all reasonable lines of inquiry during a suspect's period of detention" so that the Full Code Test can be applied instead (para 6.2).
In practice it's a client in custody whom the police want kept in for court, while forensic results, phone downloads, CCTV or witness statements are still outstanding.
Who makes the decision
Threshold Test cases "are usually charged by a prosecutor" (Director's Guidance, para 6.12). The police can use it in some cases, but with limits (para 6.13):
- it can't be used to charge a summary-only, non-imprisonable offence;
- if the police use it for a summary-only imprisonable offence, they must record how each of the five conditions is met, so the prosecutor can review it before the first hearing;
- it can't be used for either-way offences suitable for sentence in the magistrates' court where a guilty plea is expected, because the Full Code Test should have been met.
So in most cases you're dealing with a CPS decision, not the custody officer's. Any representations need to reach the prosecutor. Ask the officer to pass them on, or to forward something in writing.
The five conditions
"All five conditions must be met before the Threshold Test can be applied" (Code, para 5.2). If one fails, the others don't need considering: "the Threshold Test cannot be applied and the suspect cannot be charged".
- Reasonable grounds to suspect the person committed the offence. This is "an objective assessment of the evidence" that "must consider the impact of any defence or information that the suspect has put forward or on which they might rely" (para 5.3). The material must be capable of being put into admissible form, reliable and credible (para 5.4).
- Further evidence can be obtained within a reasonable period, so that all the evidence together "is capable of establishing a realistic prospect of conviction in accordance with the Full Code Test" (para 5.5). "The likely further evidence must be identifiable and not merely speculative" (para 5.6).
- The seriousness or circumstances justify an immediate charging decision. This "should be linked to the level of risk created by granting bail" (para 5.8).
- Continuing substantial grounds to object to bail under the Bail Act 1976. That must rest on "a proper risk assessment, which reveals that the suspect is not suitable to be bailed, even with substantial conditions" (para 5.9).
- The public interest requires a charge, applying the public interest stage of the Full Code Test "based on the information available at that time" (para 5.10).
What the prosecutor has to weigh on condition 2
Paragraph 5.7 lists what prosecutors must consider. It's the most useful list in section 5 for a rep, because each point is a question you can ask:
- the nature, extent and admissibility of the likely further evidence, and its impact;
- the charges all the evidence will support;
- why the evidence isn't already available;
- how long it will take, including whether it could be got within any available detention period;
- whether the delay in applying the Full Code Test is reasonable.
Review after charge
"A decision to charge under the Threshold Test must be kept under review" (Code, para 5.11). The prosecutor should be "proactive" in getting the outstanding material from the police "in accordance with an agreed timetable". The Full Code Test must be applied as soon as that material arrives and, in Crown Court cases, "usually before the formal service of the prosecution case" (para 5.11).
The Director's Guidance adds that the outstanding material goes in "a shared action plan containing an agreed timetable", and that the police must tell the prosecutor at once if the timetable is slipping or the new material means the test should no longer apply (para 6.15).
Practice notes for police station reps
First published 11 November 2025. Updated 19 October 2026. Rewritten 31 October 2026 (Code for Crown Prosecutors eighth edition and Director's Guidance on Charging sixth edition, re-checked on cps.gov.uk).
At the police station
When you're told the police are seeking a Threshold Test charge, ask:
- What evidence is there now?
- What further evidence is expected, and what exactly is it? (It has to be identifiable, para 5.6.)
- Why isn't it already available?
- How long will it take to get, and could it be got within the detention period?
- What are the substantial grounds to object to bail?
- Why wouldn't conditions such as residence, non-contact, an exclusion zone or a curfew deal with that risk?
Then make short, focused representations on the weakest condition. Usually that's condition 4. Paragraph 5.9 says prosecutors "should not accept, without careful enquiry, any unjustified or unsupported assertions about risk". Put forward a realistic package of conditions and explain why it answers the risk the police have described. Write down what you said, when and to whom, and tell the instructing firm.
If any condition isn't met, the client can't be charged on the Threshold Test. The police then have to decide whether to keep them in detention for further investigation, or release them under investigation or on bail. If there's no prospect of the case ever meeting the evidential stage of the Full Code Test, it must be no further action (Director's Guidance, para 6.11).
After charge
Once the client is charged, it's the custody officer who decides under s.38(1) of PACE whether they're released, on bail or without bail, or kept in custody for court.
If they're kept in, make sure the firm dealing with the case at court knows it's a Threshold Test charge. That matters for the bail application and for chasing the Full Code Test review.
Custody time limits run from the first appearance and act as a backstop:
- Magistrates' court: 56 days to the start of summary trial for a summary offence; 70 days for an either-way offence, reduced to 56 if the court decides on summary trial within 56 days (Prosecution of Offences (Custody Time Limits) Regulations 1987, reg 4).
- Crown Court: 182 days from sending to the start of trial, less any time already spent in custody in the magistrates' court (reg 5).
To extend a time limit the prosecution must show it "has acted with all due diligence and expedition" (Prosecution of Offences Act 1985, s.22(3)(b)). The CPS's own guidance applies the standard in R v Manchester Crown Court, ex parte McDonald [1998] EWHC 319 (Admin), [1999] 1 Cr App R 409, [1999] 1 WLR 841: the court must require "such diligence and expedition as would be shown by a competent prosecutor conscious of his duty to bring the case to trial as quickly as reasonably and fairly possible" (Lord Bingham CJ).
Worked example (invented)
The client is arrested for a s.18 wounding after a fight outside a pub. Two witness statements describe a man in a red jacket. CCTV has been seized but not yet viewed, and the knife has gone for forensic testing. The police tell you they're seeking a Threshold Test charge and a remand.
Questions worth asking: Is the CCTV identifiable and when will it be viewed? Could that happen within the detention clock? What are the bail grounds? Is there a named complainant the client might contact? A realistic package might be residence at a stated address, no contact with named witnesses, and an exclusion zone around the pub. Make the point that conditions answer the risk, so condition 4 isn't met.
Advising the client
Keep it plain: "You've been charged on a lower test than usual. The prosecution says more evidence is coming. They must review the case when it arrives, and if it doesn't support the charge, the case should be dropped." Don't promise that will happen. Further evidence often does turn up.
Further reading
- Code for Crown Prosecutors, section 5: the Threshold Test (CPS)
- Director's Guidance on Charging, sixth edition (CPS)
- Custody time limits (CPS legal guidance)
- Prosecution of Offences (Custody Time Limits) Regulations 1987, reg 4
- Prosecution of Offences Act 1985, s.22
Sources (checked 4 November 2026): Code for Crown Prosecutors (eighth edition), paras 4.1, 4.6, 4.9–4.10 and 5.1–5.11; Director's Guidance on Charging (sixth edition), paras 6.1–6.2 and 6.11–6.15; PACE 1984 s.38(1); Prosecution of Offences (Custody Time Limits) Regulations 1987, regs 4 and 5; Prosecution of Offences Act 1985, s.22(3); CPS legal guidance on custody time limits; R v Manchester Crown Court, ex parte McDonald [1998] EWHC 319 (Admin), [1999] 1 WLR 841.
General information only. Not legal advice.