Youth Justice: Representing Under 18s at Police Stations
Anyone who appears to be under 18 must be treated as a juvenile under PACE and the Codes, unless there's clear evidence they're older (Code C 1.5). Young clients get extra protections, and they need more from you: more time, plainer language, and careful handling of the appropriate adult.
Extra protections in custody
- Appropriate adult (AA): the custody officer must tell the AA about the detention and ask them to come to the station (Code C 3.15). The AA can be a parent or guardian, a local authority or care representative, a social worker, or another responsible adult who isn't connected with the police (1.7(a)).
- Informing a parent or carer: the person responsible for the juvenile's welfare must be told about the arrest, as soon as practicable (PACE s.57; Code C 3.13).
- No interview without an AA, except in urgent cases authorised by a superintendent (11.15, 11.18).
- Legal advice: the AA should consider whether legal advice is needed. If the young person doesn't want a solicitor, the AA can ask for one on their behalf, although the young person can't be forced to see the solicitor (6.5A).
The AA's role
The AA's job is to safeguard the young person's rights, entitlements and welfare (1.7A). In interview they can support and advise the young person, observe whether the interview is being conducted properly and fairly, and help communication (11.17).
The AA is not a lawyer, and what's said to them isn't privileged in the way your advice is. Usually, consult with the young person privately first, then explain the position to the AA. Be careful with parents who are also witnesses, are angry with the child, or want to answer for them. If the AA isn't suitable, raise it with the custody officer.
Advising a young client
- Use short, plain sentences, and check understanding by asking them to explain it back.
- Be honest about the possible outcomes, including youth diversion.
- Ask about school, care status, any youth offending team involvement, and any learning or communication needs.
- Watch for suggestibility and the wish to "just get it over with".
Outcomes
- Youth caution or youth conditional caution (Crime and Disorder Act 1998, ss.66ZA and 66A), after an admission and with consent. A youth caution is spent immediately under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act and isn't automatically disclosed on a standard or enhanced DBS check.
- Community resolution or other diversion through the youth offending team.
- Charge, usually to the youth court.
After charge: detention
If a young person is charged and refused bail, the custody officer must arrange for them to be moved to local authority accommodation, unless that's impracticable, or (for those aged 12 or over) no secure accommodation is available and other local authority accommodation wouldn't protect the public from serious harm (PACE s.38(6)). Ask what's been done and make sure it's recorded.
Practical checklist
- Confirm age and who the AA is
- Check the custody record for when the AA was contacted and arrived
- Consult privately with the young person
- Brief the AA on their role
- Push for diversion where appropriate
- Record everything, including the AA's conduct in interview
Sources
- PACE Code C 2023 (GOV.UK): paras 1.5, 1.7, 1.7A, 3.13, 3.15, 6.5A, 11.15–11.18
- PACE 1984, ss.38 and 57 (legislation.gov.uk)
- Crime and Disorder Act 1998 (legislation.gov.uk)
General information only.